What Has Attachment to Do With Neuroplastic Symptoms?
We are delighted to welcome Mags Clark Smith to the Living Proof blog. Mags is a pain relief movement specialist with over 25 years’ experience in Movement and Psychology. She works in private practice, teaches approaches to resolving chronic pain internationally and runs teacher-training programmes. A trained Whole Health Medicine Institute practitioner, Mags has contributed to chronic pain research at University College Cork and is one of four editors of 'Psychophysiological Disorders: Trauma Informed, Interprofessional Diagnosis and Treatment’ (2019). You can learn more about Mags and her work at resolvingchronicpain.com.
In this blog, Mags explores the connection between attachment and chronic neuroplastic symptoms – and how understanding these links can support us on our healing journeys.
You probably didn’t need a researcher to tell you that the bond between a parent and a newborn is special. But why is it significant? Science has spent seventy years finding out, and in my work with people recovering from neuroplastic symptoms, the answer matters far more than anyone expects.
Meet Charlie, although that is not his real name, his story is real. As a child and teenager, he had to endure a situation at home that was extremely difficult: his older brother was very poorly and had many disruptive needs. His parents loved him, but they were exhausted trying to protect his brother from hurting himself and other family members. There was a constant background of shouting, often incoherent shouting. He learned to keep quiet so as not to draw attention to himself. He was diligent at school and college, but studying was an uphill battle, because it is hard to concentrate when you don’t feel safe.
Seventy years of research, from Bowlby to Beebe to Gabor Maté, shows how our earliest bonds shape the way we cope later in life.
Bowlby: Attachment Matters
In the mid-twentieth century, the British psychiatrist John Bowlby made a radical claim: a child’s need for a close, consistent caregiver is not a nice-to-have. It is a biological necessity, as fundamental as food or warmth. When a baby is frightened or overwhelmed, an attachment system switches on: the crying, the reaching, the clinging that pulls the caregiver close.

When the caregiver reliably shows up with warmth, a child can build an internal working model along the lines of: people can be trusted, echoing thoughts and feelings such as ‘I am safe’, and ‘I am worth caring for’. Where that isn’t the case, the opposite may happen, a sense of not being safe takes hold. An internal alarm spikes: stay alert, manage this alone, don’t trust anyone. Either template is laid down early, I define the most impressionable period as from in utero to around eight years old. The template gets hard wired into our unconscious mind and affects how our nervous system responds. The template may serve us well when we are young but not so much when we are adults. Charlie was hypervigilant at home, and his body learned to stay on guard, by his mid-twenties this no longer served him.
What Happens in Those First Face-to-Face Moments
Dr Beatrice Beebe, a psychologist at Columbia University, filmed mothers and four-month-old babies on split-screen video. In fractions of a second, each adjusts expressions, sounds and movements in response to the other, an improvised dance that neither is choreographing. How sensitively a mother follows her baby’s lead predicts attachment quality months later. Not perfectly, because life is messier than that, but meaningfully. And the baby is shaping the interaction too. Even the youngest infants are active participants in co-creating the relationship that will shape them.
When Attachment Costs Us Ourselves
The Canadian physician Gabor Maté points to a central tension in growing up: attachment versus authenticity. Every child needs to stay close to their caregivers. But every child also has real feelings, real needs, a real self. When expressing them risks upsetting the adult you depend on, most children quietly shelve their authenticity. It isn’t a conscious choice. It’s survival. Maté argues that this early self-abandonment has a long tail: anxiety, depression, chronic illness, a persistent sense of not quite knowing who you are. It is not about blame, but it is a pattern worth recognising.
Charlie slowly became aware that he automatically suppressed his feelings. Beneath his amiable everyday exterior there was anger with nowhere to go. The body holds what the mind had to let go.
Why It Matters for the Rest of Your Life
The landmark ACE (Adverse Childhood Experiences) studies found a striking relationship between disrupted early nurturing and later heart disease, autoimmune conditions, mental illness and addiction. Securely attached children, by contrast, tend to regulate their emotions more easily and handle stress better.
None of this is a life sentence. Research over the last 10 years confirms that the brain stays plastic, and good relationships, therapy and self-awareness all have real reparative power. Perfect attunement in parenting is an unrealistic goal. It just isn’t possible, we are human, and most importantly, it isn’t what children need. What they do need is to know that things do inevitably go wrong sometimes but solutions can be found and emotional connections can be repaired. What matters is repair, the return to connection after a rupture. The ‘Still Face’ experiment, when mothers interact with their infants happily then still their face, causing the infant distress until the mother animates her face again, demonstrates this beautifully.

Charlie’s long-term relationship with his girlfriend is built on trust, and he feels safe with her. Leaning into that safety has allowed him to look at his repressed anger, revealing to himself that it has bubbled beneath the surface for a very long time. Through the Resolving Chronic Pain tools (which can be explored here), he now releases physical tension, and processes feelings by writing and speaking honestly. In a letter to his younger self, he wrote about how long he had carried that anger, and reminded himself that ‘you do not have to carry that anger along in your body forever.’
He ended: ‘For now, I just want you to know that there is nothing wrong with you as a person. Your body is not betraying you. It is responding to everything it has had to carry. You are still worthy of being believed. You are still safe. And one day, all of this will begin to make sense.’
Main Takeaways
Attachment is a biological need. Early care shapes the nervous system, not just our thoughts.
Children protect the bond by hiding feelings. The body can carry what was never expressed.
Hypervigilance and suppression are intelligent adaptations. They are not flaws.
Good enough is enough. Repair matters more than perfection.
Attachment patterns can change. Safe relationships, honest expression and self-awareness all help.
Suggestions of Things to Do
Ask yourself what your body learned about safety when you were young.
Notice when you keep quiet to keep the peace, and what you feel in your body at that moment.
Write an unsent letter to your younger self, naming what they carried and what they needed to hear.
Choose one safe person and share one real feeling with them.
Release anger physically and honestly, through writing, movement or speaking aloud.

References:
Bowlby, J. (1969). Attachment and Loss, Vol. 1.
Beebe, B. et al. (2010, 2016, 2020). Mother–infant research.
Maté, G. (2022). The Myth of normal.
Felitti, V.J. et al. (1998). ACE Study, American Journal of Preventive Medicine.
The Still Face experiment: Tronick et al. (1978)
Why Attachment Matters RCP Blog: https://www.resolvingchronicpain.com/blog/2026/7/14/why-attachment-matters




